It is quite distressing to see directors who, purely because of
their own ineptitude, waste the enormous talent they have at their
disposal. Time stars
Prabhu Deva and Simran, who have appeared in some good movies in
this year, has Ilaiyaraja's music and good photography. But inept
direction and a muddled screenplay make a mess of the already
flimsy story, resulting in one of the worst movies of the year.
Srinivasa Murthy(Prabhu) is a painter (though he walks around
with a guitar and doesn't seem to have an actual job). He lives
with his widowed mother(Ambika) and has a rich friend Dilip
(Bablu). Dilip's father(Devan) supports them though his wife
disapproves of Srinivas and his mother. Srinivas places a
matrimonial advertisement in the paper, revealing his inclination
towards painting and poetry. Impressed by it, Thulasi(Simran)
responds and the engagement date is fixed. But Dilip's father,
who goes to fix up the wedding, has a past history with
Thulasi's father(Nasser) and the wedding is cancelled. Thulasi
goes to Singapore to forget her troubles and by a strange turn
of events, saves Dilip's life. Dilip falls in love with her
(shades of the Hollywood movie While You Were Sleeping here)
and when Srinivas realises this, he decides to sacrifice his
love for his friend.
The whole film is characterised by some of the most inept
filmmaking this side of Monisha
En Monalisa. The direction is amateurish and the screenplay
is shoddy and frequently confusing. One example is the flashback
involving Devan, Nasser and their sisters. This important
sequence, which lays the base for several incidents, seems
hurried and is handled so quickly that for a while, I had trouble
understanding the exact relationships between the main people
involved. Things get worse in the second half when the movie
begins shifting so frequently between Vishakapatnam and Alleppey
that it is impossible to realise where the movie is at any time.
Logic is completely absent and things keep happening for which
there could be no reasonable explanations. For example, there is
a guy who keeps taking pictures of Simran and she is understandably
annoyed. But later, she suddenly trusts him enough to travel to a
foreign land with him. Incongruities like this keep popping up
throughout the movie with people showing up at places conveniently
with no thought of how they could be there in the first place
(For example, Mouli and his family showing up unnannounced at
Charlie's house).
The script is lame and does nothing to help the proceedings.
A longwinded speech by a priest near the end was particularly
painful.
The initial phone communication between Prabhu Deva and Simran
offers the few bright spots in the movie. With his friends
invading his privacy at one end and Simran struggling to keep
his phone calls secret at the other, the sequence manages to
bring a smile to the lips. So also the meeting between them in
Singapore when he tries to become her friend. Prabhu Deva's
antics while he tries to worm his way into her heart as a friend
before revealing his true identity, are cute.
Reminding one of En Swaasa Kaatre ,
here too, the moronic story unwinds against the backdrop of
some gorgeous locales. The fields and streams of Kerala are
lovingly captured by the camera, especially during the song
sequences. Ilaiyaraja has tuned some melodious numbers with
Niram Pirithu... being tops (though its effect is
somewhat dimmed by its occurring at a time when the movie was
dragging and one couldn't wait for it to end). Inexplicably,
Naan Thanga Roja..., my favorite song in the album, was
absent from the movie.
Prabhu Deva once again opts to mask his dancing talents during
the song sequences. While that worked in movies like Minsaara
Kanavu and Ninaivirukkum
Varai, which were much better movies, here it is just one
more reason not to see the movie. Simran who seemed be showing good
improvment in her acting talents in
Thullaadha Manamum Thullum
and Vaali seems
lost here. The scene where reacts to her father's death exposes
her limitations. As in Kannu
Padappogudhaiyaa, Radhika Choudhary is once again pushed
to the background by Simran and doesn't make any kind of an
impression. Manivannan has one of his least funny comedy tracks.
Bablu irritates, especially during his over-acting at his engagement.
An unbearably bad time at the theater.
|